South African court dismisses government appeal over planned coal power
The story at a glance
On 30 October 2026, South Africa’s Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed the government’s appeal over a 1,500 MW allocation for new coal-fired generation in the 2019 Integrated Resource Plan. The appeal concerned a High Court order that had set aside the allocation and related decisions. 12
The appeal court did not endorse the High Court’s constitutional findings. It dismissed the case because the 2025 Integrated Resource Plan had replaced the 2019 plan, leaving the challenged determination without practical effect under the current framework. The High Court order setting aside the allocation remains in place. 134
What you need to know
- The High Court ruled in December 2024 that the ministerial determination, the regulator’s concurrence and part of the 2019 plan providing for 1,500 MW of new coal-fired generation were unlawful and inconsistent with the Constitution. The minister appealed that order. 2
- The appeal court relied on section 16(2)(a)(i) of the Superior Courts Act, which allows dismissal where an appeal would have no practical effect. It found that the 2025 plan had superseded the planning basis for the 2020 determination challenged in the case. 1
- Published on 28 October 2025, the new Integrated Resource Plan superseded the 2019 plan and makes no provision for coal-fired power. This change is central to the appeal court’s reasoning: the old coal allocation is no longer part of the current plan. 13
- The dismissal does not mean the appeal court confirmed the High Court’s constitutional reasoning. The Supreme Court of Appeal expressly said its judgment did not endorse the High Court order on the merits, so the constitutional questions were not resolved by this appeal. 14
- Nor did the judgment establish a permanent ban on new coal power. The court said the challenged 2020 determination cannot be implemented under the current framework. Pursuing the same capacity would require a new determination and compliance with statutory requirements, including those applying to any departure from the 2025 plan. 14
Why this matters
The ruling leaves the High Court order setting aside the 1,500 MW allocation in place, while making clear that the appeal’s dismissal was about the changed planning framework rather than a decision on the constitutional merits. For energy governance, the distinction matters: the 2025 plan currently contains no coal-fired power provision, but the court has not ruled out a future proposal. Any such proposal would need a new determination and would be assessed against applicable statutory requirements. 123
What happens next
Any attempt to pursue the same coal capacity would require a fresh determination under the current legal framework, rather than relying on the 2020 decision. The appeal court said a departure from the 2025 plan would have to meet statutory requirements. The supplied reporting does not say whether the government intends to seek further review or make a new determination. 14
What's still unclear
Read the reporting
This WildNews briefing synthesises and summarises reporting from the sources below. WildNews did not produce the original reporting. Learn more about how we use AI
Was this story useful?
Your anonymous feedback helps us make future WildNews briefings more useful.