Policy & GovernanceOceans & Coasts

NOAA proposes allowing commercial fishing in parts of Pacific monument

Ecological / Economic70 / 30
EcologicalEconomic
Evidence / Opinion82 / 18
EvidenceOpinion
Consensus / Contested72 / 28
ConsensusContested
a small island in the middle of a body of water
Illustrative image by Gherardo Sava on Unsplash | Unsplash License
Fisheries

Published 13 November 2026. This story may be updated as it develops.

The story at a glance

NOAA Fisheries has proposed changing commercial fishing rules for waters 50 to 200 nautical miles from Johnston Atoll, Wake Island and Jarvis Island, within the Pacific Islands Heritage Marine National Monument. The agency published the proposed rule on 9 November 2026. It concerns the monument’s expansion waters, rather than opening the entire protected area to commercial fishing. 12

The proposal is not final. NOAA is accepting public comments through 9 December 2026. The agency says commercial fishing would remain subject to existing fishery laws and regulations, while conservation groups dispute its assessment of the likely environmental effects. The available reporting describes anticipated impacts, not measured effects from fishing under the proposed rule. 1236

What you need to know

  • The proposed area is defined by distance from three places: waters between 50 and 200 nautical miles from Johnston Atoll, Wake Island and Jarvis Island. This geographic limit matters because the proposal does not cover every part of the monument, and NOAA identifies other waters where commercial fishing would remain prohibited. 123
  • NOAA says commercial fishing would still be prohibited within 50 nautical miles of Johnston Atoll, Wake Island and Jarvis Island. The proposed change would also leave prohibitions in place around Kingman Reef, Palmyra Atoll, Howland Island and Baker Island, according to the agency’s frequently asked questions. 3
  • The proposed rule would align fishing regulations with presidential proclamations issued in 2025 and 2026. NOAA describes the action as being taken in light of a court order. These are the agency’s stated grounds for the proposal; the supplied material does not establish what final regulatory wording NOAA will adopt. 2
  • NOAA anticipates that most environmental effects would be negligible and says existing fishery rules would continue to apply. Earthjustice and other opponents argue that reopening the specified waters risks harm to marine ecosystems and protected species. These are competing assessments of a proposal, not evidence of impacts already observed under it. 356
  • Potential economic gains are also contested. NOAA describes possible benefits from access to fishing grounds and lower fuel or operating costs. Earthjustice reports that agency analysis does not expect the proposal to increase total fish catch. The supplied reporting therefore presents possible business benefits without establishing that the change would raise overall catches. 36

Why this matters

The decision would determine whether commercial fishing is permitted in a defined part of a marine monument, while keeping restrictions in other specified waters. That makes the rule’s geographic scope and the eventual assessment of ecological effects central to its significance. NOAA’s expectation of mostly negligible effects and conservation groups’ warnings remain competing forecasts, so the proposal itself does not show what consequences a change would have for marine life or fishing activity. 136

What happens next

The public-comment period runs until 9 December 2026, and NOAA has not yet made the proposal a final rule. Whether the agency adopts it after considering comments remains open. The final rule and supporting environmental analysis will also need to clarify what conclusions NOAA reaches about protected species, cultural resources and fishing activity. 125

What's still unclear

  • It is not yet known whether NOAA will adopt the proposal after reviewing public comments. 15
  • The final environmental analysis and any resulting rule have not yet established how the change would affect protected species, cultural resources or fishing activity. 23

Read the reporting

This WildNews briefing synthesises and summarises reporting from the sources below. WildNews did not produce the original reporting. Learn more about how we use AI

Was this story useful?

Your anonymous feedback helps us make future WildNews briefings more useful.

WILDNEWS WEEKLY DIGEST

One clear conservation briefing, every Friday.

Get the essential stories, context and developments in one clear briefing every Friday.