Most boulders placed to deter trawling reportedly lie within planned Norfolk Vanguard wind farm site
The story at a glance
Greenpeace says it placed boulders weighing up to two tonnes in the Southern North Sea Marine Protected Area (MPA) to deter bottom trawling. The Marine Management Organisation (MMO) has published positions relayed by Greenpeace via HM Coastguard, while stating that it has not independently verified all the coordinates. It advises sea users to take the reported positions into account. 13
The reported locations have raised questions about planned offshore development: The Guardian reports that most lie within the Norfolk Vanguard wind farm project area. RWE is checking the exact positions and investigating possible implications for surveys, construction and undersea cables. The available reporting establishes neither a construction delay nor a conservation benefit for harbour porpoises. 23
What you need to know
- The Southern North Sea site is identified by the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC) as important for harbour porpoises. Its conservation objectives include maintaining porpoise viability, avoiding significant disturbance, and maintaining supporting habitat and prey availability. Those objectives provide the conservation context for the reported seabed intervention. 5
- Greenpeace says the boulders are intended to deter bottom trawling and describes the barrier as closing 116 km² to that fishing method. This area figure and the organisation’s analysis of fishing activity are Greenpeace claims. The reviewed sources provide no independent evidence that the placements have reduced trawling or improved conditions for porpoises. 35
- The MMO’s published positions were relayed by Greenpeace via HM Coastguard, and the organisation cautions that it has not independently verified all of them. Its advice is for sea users to take the reported positions into account. The published coordinates should therefore not be read as independent verification of every boulder’s location. 1
- The wind farm plans concern two projects, Vanguard West and Vanguard East. RWE and KKR announced a planned investment of around £12 billion and a combined capacity of 2.8 gigawatts. These figures describe the developers’ plans; RWE’s announcement does not assess the boulders or their possible effects on the projects. 4
- The practical implications for Norfolk Vanguard remain under assessment. The Guardian reports that RWE is checking the boulders’ exact positions and investigating possible effects on surveys, construction and undersea cables. Greenpeace has said that claims the rocks pose a genuine obstacle are exaggerated; the reviewed reporting confirms no construction delay. 23
Why this matters
The intervention’s stated purpose connects it to an MPA whose conservation objectives include porpoise viability, disturbance, habitat and prey availability. But placement alone cannot show whether those aims are being advanced: the reviewed sources report no measured change in trawling, seabed condition or porpoise outcomes. The issue also has a practical dimension for the planned wind farm, since RWE is assessing the positions against its surveys, construction plans and undersea cables. 235
What happens next
The next documented step is RWE’s assessment of the boulders’ exact positions and possible implications for surveys, construction and cables. The MMO’s current advice is for sea users to take the reported positions into account, while recognising that it has not independently verified all coordinates. The sources reviewed report no final assessment or change to the wind farm’s timetable. 12
What's still unclear
- What are the verified positions of all the boulders relative to the wind farm’s survey, cable and construction areas? 12
- Will RWE’s assessment find that the boulders require changes to surveys or construction plans, or affect the project timetable? 2
- Do the boulders measurably deter trawling, and what effects, if any, follow for seabed habitat and harbour porpoises? 35
Read the reporting
This WildNews briefing synthesises and summarises reporting from the sources below. WildNews did not produce the original reporting. Learn more about how we use AI
Was this story useful?
Your anonymous feedback helps us make future WildNews briefings more useful.