WildlifeConservation Practice

Farmers in South Africa use fire and drumming to deter crop-raiding elephants

Ecological / Economic55 / 45
EcologicalEconomic
Evidence / Opinion72 / 28
EvidenceOpinion
Consensus / Contested82 / 18
ConsensusContested
elephant walking during daytime
Illustrative image by Nam Anh on Unsplash | Unsplash License
Elephants

Published 13 November 2026. This story may be updated as it develops.

The story at a glance

At Den Staat farm in Limpopo, farmers say elephants enter fields and damage crops. They use several deterrents, including striking metal tins, lighting fires and hanging plastic containers, but report that elephants sometimes return or become accustomed to them. The accounts describe efforts to protect crops, not evidence that any one method works consistently. 1

A 2025 policy brief describes Den Staat as lying between sections of Mapungubwe National Park, where a deteriorated park fence allows wildlife movement. The wider setting is therefore part of the reported conflict, but the sources do not establish how effective the farmers’ methods are over time. 21

What you need to know

  • The PLAAS policy brief places Den Staat between sections of Mapungubwe National Park and reports that a deteriorated park fence allows wildlife movement. This provides context for elephants reaching farmland, though the supplied research does not quantify how often they move onto the farm or identify a particular route used during crop raids. 2
  • Farmers interviewed by Mongabay described beating metal tins, lighting fires and hanging plastic containers to deter elephants. They said the animals sometimes return or become accustomed to the methods. These are local accounts of practical responses, rather than a systematic comparison of the different deterrents or evidence of lasting crop protection. 1
  • The policy brief also documents elephant crop damage and effects on community members’ farming and livelihoods. That means the issue extends beyond the presence of wildlife: losses can affect people’s ability to farm. The available material does not quantify those losses at Den Staat, or show how they vary between households or seasons. 2
  • A 2021 experiment found that wild African elephants moved farther from some human-generated seismic cues. It offers behavioural context for the possibility that elephants respond to human-made cues, but it did not test the drumming used by Den Staat farmers. Its results therefore cannot show whether striking tins reliably prevents crop damage in this setting. 41
  • A 2026 study estimated 243 elephants in Mapungubwe National Park and an annual growth rate of 18% over the preceding five years. Both figures rely on historical population data, not a new census. They describe the park-level population estimate and do not establish elephant numbers at Den Staat or explain the crop damage reported there. 31

Why this matters

The accounts bring together a documented wildlife movement setting, crop damage and the livelihood concerns of local farmers. For conservation practitioners, they show why responses to human-elephant conflict need to be considered in their local context. But the evidence here does not show that the reported deterrents deliver dependable protection, or establish a conservation outcome. Distinguishing farmers’ experience from tested effectiveness is important when assessing what the methods can achieve. 124

What happens next

The supplied reporting identifies no systematic evaluation of the Den Staat deterrents or a confirmed follow-up intervention. The central practical question remains whether the methods reduce crop losses reliably over time. The experimental study cannot answer that for farmers, because it examined different cues and conditions; the reported evidence leaves effectiveness in this setting unresolved. 14

What's still unclear

  • The reporting does not establish how often each deterrent prevents crop damage or how long any effect lasts. The cited experiment tested different cues and conditions, so it cannot resolve that question for Den Staat. 14

Read the reporting

This WildNews briefing synthesises and summarises reporting from the sources below. WildNews did not produce the original reporting. Learn more about how we use AI

Was this story useful?

Your anonymous feedback helps us make future WildNews briefings more useful.

WILDNEWS WEEKLY DIGEST

One clear conservation briefing, every Friday.

Get the essential stories, context and developments in one clear briefing every Friday.